The Best Online Car Buying Services for 2021 (2024)

By Gary Smith (Contributing Writer) | Published on March 2nd, 2021 | Last Updated on

By Gary Smith (Contributing Writer)
Published on March 2nd, 2021. Last Updated on .

What Are Car Buying Services?

The main goal of a car buying service is to help you purchase or lease a new or used car. This is perfect for the individual who doesn’t want to haggle for their next vehicle, a car buying service could be worth it. Below we break down the differences between a car buying concierge and a Broker.

What's the Difference Between a Car Buying Concierge and aCar Buying Broker?

The Car Buying Concierge’s main goal is to advise you on your choice of vehicles, negotiate the best price, and review the final contract. They will also even arrange to have the vehicle delivered to your desired location. Even though they normally charge an upfront fee it is in their best interest to negotiate a low price that yields the highest amount of saving for the buyer.

A Car Broker is paid by the dealer so that it can be a free service for the car buyer. While the role may be similar to the concierge in that the broker will find the vehicle, negotiate a price, and schedule the car’s delivery; the broker can also get a fee from the dealer which can make the customer suspicious if they negotiated the best price. Also, the broker might have preferences on which dealerships they have the best relationships with so the vehicle choices can be more limited.

Popular Retailer, Club, & Bank Car Buying Services

AAA

The AAA program will let you purchase your car in person or you can buy it from the comfort of your own home. You can also see what others are paying to get competitive price quotes from local dealers. There is also a chance that you can be eligible for a discount on your auto loan if you add AAA’s car buying service. With test driving, you can typically get with a local dealer to test drive it and can sometimes even have the vehicle delivered to your home if the listing includes a “Buy from Home” badge. Visit: AAA Auto Buying

AARP

Similar to being a AAA member, you can check out the many car buying services that are available on the associated website. Members can price a new or used car and connect with a local dealer to get discount pricing upfront. If you do go ahead and end up purchasing a vehicle through their program it is recommended that you report this purchase on their website. By doing so will get you a free online driving course and up to $2,000 in post-sale benefits. Visit: AARP Auto Buying

Consumer Reports

By being a member you are authorized to receive access to their Build & Buy Car Buying Service powered by TruCar as well as access to the used car marketplace by both Cars.com and TrueCar as well. Once you accept the terms and conditions which allow dealerships to contact you, they will eventually reach out with pricing on vehicles that fit your preferences. If you have a Consumer Reports membership then you will be able to see their proprietary reliability and owner satisfaction scores right in the vehicle listings. Visit:Consumer Reports

Costco Auto

By being a Costco member gives you access to the company’s car-buying services online. Dealerships in Costco’s network are hand-selected which means unlike some of the other companies on this list they aren’t powered by TrueCar. On top of this, the dealership pays a fee to participate in this program which means there will be no additional cost to you for using the car-buying service. Visit:Costco Auto

Credit Unions

Most credit unions offer some form of car buying services for their members. Some credit unions even offer additional savings if an auto loan is taken out after using the service. The biggest benefit of going to credit unions is that financing is most likely going to be better as well.

More “Personal” Car Buying Services

Your Car Buying Advocate

Their philosophy is that the key to getting an awesome car deal is by making dealerships compete. Since they serve the customer and not the dealership you can be sure that they will have your best interest in mind. Their simple, 3-Step process keeps things hassle-free and as efficient as possible:

  1. Get started with a free strategy call to define your budget and narrow down the vehicle you are looking for or are wanting to trade-in.
  2. They go to work for you by contacting dealerships and getting both trade-in quotes or proposals for the vehicle you want. They will then present you with the offers and terms in writing.
  3. Once an offer is accepted you can either pick up your vehicle or they can have it delivered to your doorstep. Visit: YourCarBuyingAdvocate.com

myHopscotch

Using myHopscotch is similar to hiring an all-in-one professional to ignore all of the games, hassles, and frustrations that the car buying process can often be. They also have a guarantee that you will spend less on purchasing your car with them than any other way without them. By them being a personal advisor, shopper/locator, negotiator, attorney, and the concierge will show you that your car buying experience will be completely stress-free while in turn giving you a great deal. Visit:myHopscotch.com

Car Pal

With their free consultation, Car Pal will show you that they can put you together with your next new or used car at the best price. They focus on taking you out of the equation when it comes to negotiating with salespeople and let them do the heavy negotiations. They also say that the amount you will save by going with Car Pal will more than cover their fee, which will save you, even more, to begin with. Visit: Car-Pal.com

Tailored Auto

Their main goal is to keep you out of the dealership as much as possible and out of the hot seat entirely. Their services include time saved, a better deal, professional service, and total fairness. With their 4 step process, they only require 1 flat-rate fee to get you in a new vehicle in less time with zero hagglings.

  1. Contact them by giving them a call or shooting them an email. They will ask a variety of questions about what you’re looking for.
  2. Once you retain their services they will do the leg work in locating the vehicle you want to the minor details. They will then negotiate an offer.
  3. They will present you with offers and walk you through the pros and cons of each to know exactly what you are buying.
  4. Once you accept an offer they will direct you to the dealer to sign all of the paperwork and finalize the deal. Visit:TailoredAuto.com

Personal Car Negotiator

By handling the entire transaction from start to finish all they need from the customer is the exact vehicle that they want that is currently in stock at a physical dealership. Once they get this info they will use every technique at their disposal to get the based possible deal. The entire negotiation system is used by dealerships across the country and is based on the premise that consumers don’t understand the math and that’s how they like it. Personal Car Negotiator combats this system due to the professionals that you work with knowing this exact system and using it against the car dealerships. Visit: PersonalCarNegotiator.com

Authority Auto

What sets Authority Auto apart is that they always look out for the customers’ best interest by not accepting any form of compensation from car dealerships. They even offer free car buying tips with no fee on your part at all. Maybe you aren’t looking for a car buying service and just better techniques to do it all yourself. Authority Auto provides this option and this shows that they care about the customer getting the best possible deal. Visit: AuthorityAuto.com

American Car Buying Service

The ACS Corp is centered around one simple motto, “If it’s good for customers, it’s good for dealers”. Their dealer services yield excellent shopper engagement by producing increased sales and profits for dealers, OEMs, lenders, website providers, and 3rd party retailers. They shape the industry with their patent-pending calculation engine known as “truPayments”, which powers their instant monthly payment figures. Their 32-year history has shown that they have served their customers with honesty and integrity. Visit: ACSCorp.com

Final Thoughts

The process of buying a car is one of the most dreadful experiences we as people face. While the notion of using a car-buying service might seem confusing or scary, be sure that this can be one of the most simple, hassle-free processes when it comes to dealing with dealerships. Most of these car-buying services only charge 1 flat rate fee which ensures you aren’t being nickeled and dimed for everything you have. While there can be a wide variety of different car buying services to choose from, we hope this list can better help you with your search.

The Best Online Car Buying Services for 2021 (2024)

FAQs

What is the best online car buying service? ›

Cars.com, Carvana, Edmunds, CarMax and TrueCar are our top recommendations for used car websites. Whether you want to find your ideal pre-owned vehicle or find the right buyer for a car you're selling, these sites are easy to use and offer excellent customer support.

What is the best website for car purchasing? ›

Some of the most popular online car buying sites include CarGurus, AutoTrader, Cars.com, TrueCar, and Hemmings. Key factors to consider when choosing an online car buying site include user-friendliness, selection of vehicles, pricing transparency, and customer reviews.

What is the best online platform to buy used cars? ›

10 Best Used Car Websites in India in 2024
  • CarTrade.
  • CarDekho.
  • CarWale.
  • Droom.
  • Spinny.
  • Cars24.
  • QuikrCars.
  • OLX Autos Sale Car.
Jan 18, 2024

What car website pays the most? ›

Cars.com is our top pick for the best place to sell your car online — you can sell directly to the site or list your vehicle on a private-sale marketplace. Carmax offers the best prices for used vehicles when selling a car online. CarBrain is our top recommendation for selling an old or damaged car online.

Who is better, CarMax or Carvana? ›

Both Carvana and CarMax advertise no-haggle pricing, but Carvana offers a seamless selling process that helps it come out ahead in our rankings. We give Carvana the edge over CarMax as a car selling website. Our team rates CarMax just slightly ahead of Carvana for its car buying services.

What is better than TrueCar? ›

Cars.com is the best app for buying and selling a car because it has a large number of listings and offers helpful search tools. Some car buying apps aggregate dealer listings, while others sell inventory directly. Edmunds, TrueCar and Carfax are good apps for researching vehicles and pricing information in-depth.

What is the largest online car dealer in the US? ›

Carvana, the largest online car dealer, has focused exclusively on online operations, forgoing funding for brick-and-mortar dealerships.

Can you negotiate prices at Carvana? ›

Carvana does not negotiate prices on sales or purchases of vehicles. The price you see on an offer is the price you get, with no wiggle room.

Which is the best site to check cars? ›

How can I learn a vehicle's history?
  • AutoCheck.com.
  • Carfax.com.
  • Vinaudit.com.

Who gives me the most money for my car? ›

You can sell your used car for the most money with CarMax, based on our research. Most online dealers provide instant offers and will pick up your car for you. A private sale could bring the most value, but it takes more work on your end.

Who pays more than Carvana? ›

The Winner: CarMax
CarMaxCarvana
Location Count248 locations40 locations
PickupOnly available in certain regionsPickup available
In-store experienceEasy and fastNot applicable
My offer$23,600$20,929
1 more row
Mar 29, 2024

Which is the best site to sell your car on? ›

The best websites for selling your car in 2024
  • Carwow.
  • Auto Trader.
  • Exchange My Car.
  • We Buy Any Car.
  • eBay Motors.
  • Gumtree.
  • Facebook Marketplace.
  • Car Converter/Car TakeBack.
Jul 16, 2024

Is it worth it to use a car buying service? ›

Hire a reputable car-buying service

For individuals who want to avoid the hassles of shopping for their next vehicle, professional car-buying services can not only save them time, but, potentially, thousands of dollars.

What website tells you what you should pay for a car? ›

Edmunds True Market Value® (TMV®), also known as Edmunds Suggested Price, is a pricing system that helps you determine the average transaction price — or what others are paying — for new or used vehicles in your area so that you can begin your negotiations with a fair price in mind.

Is consumer report car buying service worth it? ›

The pricing information and guaranteed savings include eligible incentives. Consumer Reports members have saved an average of $3,101 off the MSRP with the Build & Buy Car Buying Service.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Lakeisha Bayer VM

Last Updated:

Views: 5403

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (49 voted)

Reviews: 88% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Lakeisha Bayer VM

Birthday: 1997-10-17

Address: Suite 835 34136 Adrian Mountains, Floydton, UT 81036

Phone: +3571527672278

Job: Manufacturing Agent

Hobby: Skimboarding, Photography, Roller skating, Knife making, Paintball, Embroidery, Gunsmithing

Introduction: My name is Lakeisha Bayer VM, I am a brainy, kind, enchanting, healthy, lovely, clean, witty person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.